What Is A Railroad Spike Knife – How to Forge One?

(This site is reader-supported. When you buy something using retail links on our articles, we may earn a small commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)

As the name indicates, a railroad spike knife is a knife made by forging a railroad spike. The latter is a special nail that is commonly utilized in railways as a critical part of the rail fastening system. The nail is typically used for fastening the rail track.

As a matter of fact, railroad spikes are usually free and readily available for making a variety of small tools, including useable knives. They are increasingly in use for designing a few metal artworks including bottle opener and furniture items.

Click Here to Find Out Our Favorite Handmade Railroad Spike Knife on Amazon

A railroad spike knife is a predominantly a novelty item that is usually forged for pleasure. Yes, for most people, it is a knife for looks and fun. However, it is useful as a weapon for even attacking someone.

Most of its models are made using hand due to which the appearance and size tend to change from one model to another. This post is dedicated to reveal some interesting basics of this knife and how you can make one on your own at home.

Railroad Spike Knife K11 - Unique Father's Day Gift For Him, Groomsman Gifts, Gift for Him, 6th Anniversary Gift, Groomsmen Knife

Why a Railroad Spike for Making a Knife?

A railroad spike is commonly chosen for making a knife due to its conductive properties. While holding a railway track firmly in place, the spike is resistant to wear and tear. This means that it is tough as well as strong to perform its job.

Second, unlike a shattered spike that cannot hold a track and is tough for it to be too hard, a bent rail spike is still capable of doing its job. This means that the metal using which the spike is made must be soft enough to twist without being shattered.

This property of soft metal build makes forging a breeze. Yes, metal spikes are superb options for forging. Thus, you can easily create forged knives. These spikes feature a favorable size to work with for forging and are quite malleable.

However, care should be taken to prevent hitting the spikes when they are cold. Otherwise, they are subject to cracking, although it is dependent on its concrete composition.

Luckily, a few spikes can bear cold, while the rest tend to break quickly while hammering below 1200 to 1500 degrees Fahrenheit. While retaining them hot, try hitting them once they tend to glow. This is the key to get a good railroad spike knife.

Two types of railroad spikes are popular, which are lower carbon and higher carbon. As a fact most quality blades are composed of relatively high carbon steel and are tempered after hardening. As a result, you get flexible, strong blades with a hard edge to remain sharp.

Remember, when a piece of steel composed of high carbon is heated to make it harder, it also simultaneously becomes more brittle. So, while making your railroad spike knife, do not hit hard using a hammer or else it will crack.

Which Metal Is Used to Make Railroad Spikes?

Well, this is a common question by all those who love forging and making forged knives. The best part about forging is that you can convert a piece of metal into almost anything else, provided the metallic composition is in line with the intended use.

Usually, railroad spikes are created using carbon steel. As per the carbon used, they are generally split into three categories namely, lower carbon steel as category 1, higher carbon steel as category 2, and structural steel as category 3.

It is vital to note that it is not high carbon but higher carbon. If you compare, the carbon level is not so high. These three categories are specified as per the ASTM A65-07 standard. This standard controls the railroad spikes’ requirements.

Top Railroad Spike Knives in the Market

Amazon has railroad spike knives on sale. Here is the list of popular and best railroad spike knives available.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

How to Choose a Railroad Spike for Making a Knife?

Almost all bladesmiths know to make knives using railroad spikes. However, there is a high probability that these spikes would not have enough carbon for having a strong blade. A great myth comes from a common misunderstanding that these spikes are High Carbon (HC).

Well, the issue here is that the interpretation of the term HC for the railroads is what a knife maker terms as Low Carbon (LC) mild steel. As per the specifications by the American Railway Engineering Association (AREA), only two categories of railroad spikes exist.

They are namely low carbon ones seen on straight sections and high carbon ones seen on curves and switches. The AREA has specified that the former ones are likely to have below 0.12% carbon and that the HC ones may contain below 0.30% carbon.

On the other hand, steel blades for knives usually contain 0.85 to 1.5% carbon, which is three to five times more than what is there in an HC railroad spike. The reason for this gap is that for railroads, mild steel spikes are preferable, which would bend and not break. A bent spike is still capable of grasping the rail track, while a broken one will not.

Therefore, a spike with a label of HC is likely to have around 0.4% carbon, which is equivalent to 1045 steel. Those LC spikes are fundamentally made up of mild steel.

The 1045 steel is heat treatable and is looked upon as workhorse steel. In other words, it is tough and is capable of bearing load. Thus, you will see it in heavy-duty gears and shafts. However, it is not used widely for cutting tools, as it cannot hold an edge that well.

In a nutshell, rail spikes are likely to contain less carbon due to which they will not get as hard as desired. At times, they are made up of an alloy to include copper to boost their malleability as well as prevent cracking.

As per what most people have found, the low carbon models have been in use in the past five decades in most regions across the globe in favor of the higher carbon, tougher ones.

The railroad spikes are, however, available in different variations. So, not all spikes are made up of insufficient carbon content.

Usually, unless you are investing in new spikes that are certified, it is almost impossible to find out what is inside them. If you have a metallurgist friend, you can find this out easily. Everybody will just not have one such pal for sure.

What you now need to remember is the fact that truly old models could be made of anything. You can even find a pure iron composition. So, how do you know from which an old spike is made up of? Well, for this, you need to test it a bit.

As a part of testing, consider heat-treating an old spike to see if it is possible to harden it. As no spikes are made using steel of high carbon, it is impossible to obtain a regular file for gliding across the hardened metal. This gliding is only possible when the metal is tougher or firmer than the file.

However, the railroad spikes are not so hard. Still, you will not be able to find out what the exact composition is by only heat testing. This is because there are many spikes made using low alloys with manganese and copper.

If you are truly serious about knowing the composition and need a rationally accurate method for identifying the level of metal hardness, you may not mind spending some money.

You can buy some exclusive hardness testing files and add to your toolbox. This option is the most affordable way of testing different hardness levels on your own. Having one such kit of files is useful, as it is wise to determine how hard a spike is prior to making a blade.

If you do not want to test, just do not go for any old rail spike that is too rusty. Then, the only reliable way to get the spikes for making knives is to grab from the leftovers thrown out after rail repair jobs.

If this is not possible for you, consider buying the new spikes available at affordable rates. You can even buy them in small quantities.

Making or Forging Your Own Railroad Spike Knife

Learning how to make or forge your railroad spike is also one of the initial projects that one can take while starting with blacksmithing.

Yes, there is no need for in-depth guidance for this DIY task. It is easy to visualize the intended knife’s shape and then hammer it to get the result as per this visualization.

It is that you will have to take all safety precautions such as wearing gloves and eye protectors. Otherwise, you will end up burning yourself or cutting your finger. Following are the steps to make your railroad spike knife:

  1. Inspect the Spike: This is the first step to your desired knife. At this point, you need to ensure that the spike is not too rusty. A little bit of it is okay, as it will be burned in the forging procedure. Do not try to remove it on your own.
  2. Heat the Spike Evenly: Now, the forging procedure starts from here. Heat half of the spike with the head. You can do so in a forge or working furnace. A charcoal fire with instituted air is enough. Do not be bothered about the spike’s butt, as you will not be working with that section. Heat until you get the red/orange hot look. Now, hold the spike with metallic tongs and keep it on the anvil such that the head is positioned properly. The head’s elongated edge should be pointing in the same direction as the finished blade’s sharp edge. Clamp the head and hold your wrenches to give the desired number of twists (half or full rotations).
  3. Shape the Blade and Tip: Once the spike is heated well, give it a few hits using a heavy hammer, such as the one weighing 3.5 pounds. Start by hammering and flattening the initial 1/3rd of the shaft’s length, measuring from the point back’s tip. For making the tip, you heat it and strike all four sides uniformly. Make the tip as thin and long as possible. This will include heating several times in the forge. For flattening the blade end, you need to perform evenly on both sides. Avoid hammering directly flat, as flattening it even is not the exact goal. You need to lean towards one side, as the spine is thicker than the blade. Just hold the spike flat with the section where the edge of the blade will be up and then hammering the tip using an angle. In some time, you will see how the blade is shaping. You can now easily find out the side that will be the edge to be sharpened. This is the benefit of leaned hammering. With a little bit of hammering, the shape of the knife becomes visible. So, continue heating and hammering. During this, you will be able to feel the metal’s malleability. Then, from the color, you will be able to decide when to put it back for more heating. Now, perform the following sub-steps:
    1. Now, it is time for half-face near hammering. This is where the blade becomes flattered and flickers into the handle. Start by putting the spike on the anvil’s edge and hitting using the hammer such that the latter’s center is just at the anvil’s edge. This part of the tool where the blade shapes into the handle are known as the knife’s choil. Just watch the spine simultaneously. Working it will twist it significantly, which is fine. Just keep restoring its shape along the centerline (visualize this). You can then see how to hammer one side and then the other. At the end of this sub-step, the major shape of the knife is formed.
    2. Take a lighter hammer to work more on the spike to obtain a more accurate shape. The spine at this point is quite straight and is beginning to thin out properly. You still need to hammer, flatten, and straighten the spine using the lighter hammer, as it is still too thick to suit a knife.
    3. Take even lighter hammer to perform some lighter detail work. Here, ensure that you do not focus on getting the exact knife shape, as that will be done with sanding. Just retain a bit oversized look from every facet.
    4. Use a cross peen hammer and a ball-peen hammer to work further on the choil part. Doing so allows giving the desired shape of your choice.
    5. Finally, smooth out to give an even and flat surface. For this, simply use a planishing hammer. You can also use the ball peen hammer’s flat end. With this, the forging process is done!
  4. Clean the Blade: Use all power tools to clean the newly formed blade and give it the final shape. You can use the belts, starting with a heavy grit and then switching to medium grit. This is also how we switched hammers while forging. During this process, consider using a file to give the intended final shape. In the absence of a belt sander, a file is useful for both cleaning and shaping tasks. If you are using a file, consider a mill file, as it as an array of parallel cutting lines and not crosshatching. Such a file goes only in the forward direction to make these tasks easier for you.
  5. Harden the Knife: You now need to heat the knife for making it strong and hold a sharp edge. To harden the knife, heat it to red hot at around 1500 degrees F. The temperature is right when a magnet stops sticking to it. At this desired temperature, put the blade quickly in any oil, whether automobile or vegetable; new or used. The knife is finally hardened. Well, this also means that the knife is brittle, hardness also brings brittleness.
  6. Temper the Knife: The hardened knife is prone to shattering. Thus, it is essential to soften it a bit by tempering it a bit. To do so, heat it a bit at 500 degrees F. To know whether it is at the right temperature or not, look at the steel’s color when it heats. Now, allow the knife to cool. Then, clean it up using an abrasive paper or sandpaper. With this, the scales come out. Gradually and by keeping the flame a bit far and even along the blade’s length, heat the blade till you see a wheat color. Well, this is the right temperature. Now finally, quench once more. The hardened knife is now tempered.
  7. Polish the Knife: This is the last step to follow if you wish to give your knife some shine. Keep some emery papers ready for performing this step. Start using the heavy grits and then end the procedure with the finer grits. For example, you may begin with 80-100 grits, move to 180, and then choose 220, 400, and 600. For mirror polishing, consider going up to 1200-grit, fine paper.


A railroad spike knife is made from a railroad spike that is widely used in the railway industry. While you can buy a readymade railroad spike knife, it is easy and fun to make one such knife at home with full safety measures. The main process here is forging followed by hardening and tempering.